Bad Wheel Bearing vs. Bad Tire: Understanding and Resolving Mystery Noises in Your Car

by parker
YouTube video


When driving your car, you may experience unusual sounds that can be difficult to diagnose. One common dilemma is determining whether the noise is caused by a bad wheel bearing or a bad tire. While there are other possible culprits such as issues with the differential or transmission, wheel bearings and tires are often the main suspects. In this article, we will guide you through the process of identifying and resolving these mysterious noises.

Step 1: Checking the Condition of Your Tires

To begin the diagnosis, it is crucial to inspect the overall condition of your tires. While visually examining them can provide some insight, it is best to physically feel the tire for abnormalities. Run your hand along the tread, paying attention to the inside of the tire as well. If you notice cupping, where the tread is uneven and choppy, it could indicate tire issues.

Step 2: Evaluating the Wheel Bearing

To determine if a bad wheel bearing is the cause of the noise, you will need to lift the tire off the ground and perform a simple test. Grab the tire at the 12 o’clock and 6 o’clock positions and try to rock it forward and backward. If you feel any play or movement, it is likely a sign of a bad wheel bearing. Additionally, an in-and-out motion can further confirm this suspicion. However, it is essential to note that different vehicles have various wheel bearing setups. Therefore, it is crucial to consult your vehicle’s manual or seek professional advice.

Step 3: Spinning the Wheel

Once the tire is off the ground, give it a spin. Be attentive to any abnormal noises, such as the brake pads touching the rotor. If all sounds seem normal, spin the wheel in both directions and listen for any unusual sounds. You may also feel vibrations, indicating potential issues with the wheel bearing.

Identifying a Bad Tire: The Cupping Effect

If the wheel bearing seems fine, it is time to investigate the tire itself. Cupping can cause significant noise and discomfort while driving. To determine whether cupping is present, use a rubber hose or similar object to highlight any gaps between the tire tread. When the light shines through these gaps, it indicates cupping. By rolling the tire on the floor, you may also hear the distinct noise associated with cupping, resembling a bouncing basketball.

Comparing Decibel Readings

To gauge the severity of the noise, it is beneficial to compare decibel readings using a decibel meter. By installing a spare tire with optimal tread depth and taking a ride, you can establish a baseline for the noise level. Then, replace the suspected bad tire with the spare and repeat the experiment. While the decibel difference may not be significant, the subjective experience of the noise can be significantly reduced with the replacement tire.

Differentiating Between Bad Bearings and Tires

To further differentiate between bad wheel bearings and bad tires, you can conduct a steering test. Find a straight road where you can safely turn left and right at around 30-40 miles per hour. If the noise comes and goes while turning, it suggests a wheel bearing issue. For example, if you suspect the right front wheel bearing, turning left will cause the noise to intensify. This test can help confirm your diagnosis.

The Importance of Identical Tread Depths

Finally, it is crucial to recognize the importance of having tires with the same tread depth in all-wheel drive vehicles. This ensures that the powertrain functions properly without causing any damage. If one tire has significantly more wear than the others, it can disrupt the balance and potentially lead to long-term problems. Always check your vehicle’s specifications and consult professionals when selecting and replacing tires.


Identifying and resolving mysterious noises in your car can be a challenging task. By following the steps outlined in this article, you can distinguish between a bad wheel bearing and a bad tire. Thoroughly checking your tires for cupping, evaluating the wheel bearing for play or abnormal sounds, and conducting a steering test can help you pinpoint the source of the noise. Remember to prioritize safety and seek professional assistance if necessary. Don’t let these noises linger, as they can lead to more severe problems down the road. Maintaining your car’s components will ensure a smooth and quiet driving experience.

Related Videos

Adblock Detected

Please support us by disabling your AdBlocker extension from your browsers for our website.